1. David Cook: A controlled and beautiful vocal that showed another side of this guy's talent. Simon thought it wasn't edgy enough; I thought it was a welcome change of pace.
2. David Archuleta: Taking the Phantom song "Think of Me" and putting a contemporary Babyface spin on it was a good move. Looks like the golden child is maturing as an artist.
3. Syesha Mercado: It was smart to pick one of the most soulful Andrew Lloyd Webber tunes available. But I kinda wish she'd worn roller skates.
4. Carly Smithson: Her "Jesus Christ Superstar" was a little over the top, a lot manic and just kinda weird. Still, it wasn't exactly terrible.
5. Brooke White: She diva-ed out and started over after flubbing the first line. Not even Madonna would pull something like that! (Well, maybe she would.)
6. Jason Castro: He sang "Memory" (and dressed) like a Backstreet Boy reject. Dreadful.
Who's going home? Tough one. I'll have to go with Jason.
Comments (0)
